Peer challenge

The aim of a peer challenge is to support councils in evaluating their current performance, identifying areas of strength, and recognising opportunities for improvement.

In November 2022, we have invited a Local Government Association (LGA) peer challenge team to carry out an assessment.

The team, made up of experienced senior officers and councillors from other local authorities, visited Basingstoke to gain an understanding of how the council operates, how it is planning for the future, and how it is preparing to meet upcoming challenges.

Peer challenge report

The review was followed by a feedback report outlining the key findings. This described Basingstoke and Deane as an “ambitious council, with a legacy of strong financial management” and recognised it as “providing good quality services for its residents.”

The report was very positive saying:

“BDBC has experienced recent political and managerial change. The current Leader took on the position in February 2022, having previously served as the Deputy Leader. The council also has a relatively new Chief Executive, who joined in January 2021. The peer team heard the positive impact both have had on the organisation, hearing frequently remarks about how visible and approachable they both are.

“It was clear during the Corporate Peer Challenge (CPC) that BDBC is a driven council that has a strong desire for achievement and delivery, with passionate officers, members and partners. The talent and commitment to BDBC by officers in particular was notable, which is something that is recognised by members: "the staff are amazing here".

“The financial position of the authority is commendably stable and solid. Finances are effectively managed, and the importance of sound financial management is recognised throughout the organisation. The strong base the financial position affords the council provides it with the ability to invest in priority areas.

“Key local partners enjoy working with BDBC, and they value the importance the council places on effective partnership working. The council has many compelling stories to tell about what it has achieved in partnership and it should ensure it celebrates this both internally and externally.”

Action plan

The team developed a set of valuable recommendations outlining how the council can further enhance its effectiveness and focus on delivering the initiatives that will have the greatest impact on our area.

These recommendations underpin a comprehensive action plan designed to strengthen the council and support the delivery of its ambitious objectives.

The action plan, developed in response to the recommendations, was formally approved by Cabinet on Tuesday, 7 February 2023.

Corporate Peer Challenge Action Plan
Corporate Peer Challenge Team Recommendation Officer Lead(s) Timescales Action / Progress
Actions that sit beneath the draft council plan should be clearly prioritised, reflecting the most important ambitions. CEO and Deputy CEO Ongoing Completed
Be clear that the council’s emerging actions reflect the outcomes BDBC is seeking to achieve. For example, the
decisions being taken to achieve the net zero ambition and the local demand for homes.
CEO and Deputy CEO Ongoing Completed
Develop a planned approach to tackle the more difficult political decisions and risks that need to be taken to deliver the priorities set out in the council plan. CEO and Deputy CEO Ongoing Completed
Key performance indicators should be refined to reflect the priorities in the draft council plan and ensure that these are meaningful and measurable. The
process for reporting performance needs to be simplified giving clearer lines of
accountability.
CEO February 2023 Completed
Consider how the council can collaborate more regionally to support the delivery of the council’s priorities with a particular focus at a county level. CEO and Deputy CEO Ongoing Completed
Review the options from the constitutional review specific to the scrutiny and policy committees’ structure and function. CEO and Head of Law and Governance March 2023 Completed
Review and rationalise the member bodies within the governance framework. CEO and Head of Law and Governance May 2023 Completed
The refreshed people strategy should continue to embed the culture changes and address challenges of siloes that have been identified. CEO and Head of HR, Policy and Communications Ongoing This is the continuation of the work planned to continue to improve the culture.
Continue the strong financial governance in place whilst considering how to use the council’s resources to drive priorities. Chief Finance Officer (Section 151 Officer) Ongoing This is ongoing work as part of the council’s continued approach to financial management.
Align the policy, performance, organisational development, human resources and change functions. Given the strategic importance this should report to the Chief Executive. CEO and Head of HR, Policy and Communications March 2023 Restructure completed
Ensure capacity exists to deliver major projects for the longer-term success of the project. CEO and Deputy CEO Ongoing This is ongoing work to ensure the council is effectively resourced to deliver its major projects and is regularly reviewed
Use the new census data to review the equality, diversity and inclusion objectives for the council and the borough. Director of Customers, Digital and Improvement July 2023 Completed

Progress review

As part of the Corporate Peer Challenge process, councils are offered the opportunity to undertake a progress review with the peer team six months after agreeing their action plan.

This progress review was carried out in August 2023.

The Local Government Association (LGA) subsequently published its progress review report in October 2023. The report noted: “ The peer team was impressed with and strongly commended the breadth, depth and scale of activity that had taken place in the 10 months since the Corporate Peer Challenge, across the 12 recommendations ”.

Sign up for email updates

Receive information on council services, news and events by email.

© 2026 Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council